Report questions why LAPD mental health specialists must defer to armed officers

This is read by an automated voice.Please report any issues or inconsistencies here.

A new report from the city controller’s office questions the effectiveness of the LAPD’s signature crisis response program, saying clinicians trained in de-escalation too often are forced to defer to armed patrol officers.For years, Los Angeles Police Department officials have touted the success of the Systemwide Mental Assessment Response Team, or SMART.

But critics say the program, which pairs licensed specialists with officers in unmarked cars, is failing in the crucial initial minutes of encounters when multiple police shootings of mentally ill people have occurred.Dinah M.Manning, chief of strategic initiatives and senior advisor in the controller’s office, said the report found an “inherent contradiction” in the SMART program.Even though its purpose is to send in clinicians and tap their expertise to avoid killings, LAPD policy still requires armed patrol officers to clear a scene of any potential threats beforehand.Traditional police units almost always take charge, even on calls in which no weapon is involved, such as a person threatening to commit suicide, Manning said.Referring to SMART as a co-response program “is pretty much a misnomer in this case,” she said.

“How is it that we’re ending up with so many fatalities?”An LAPD spokesperson declined to comment in response to questions about the report.LAPD officers have opened fire 35 times this year; in recent years, department statistics showed at least a third of all police shootings involved someone with obvious signs of emotional distress.The report pointed to other shortcomings with the SMART program, which is housed within the department’s Mental Health Unit.Officers detailed to the units receive no specialized training, the report said, also finding that the department has failed to properly track uses of force on mental health-related calls.

The department’s existing use of force pol...