Why churches are closing amid a Catholic comeback

On paper, Catholicism looks like it’s having a moment.The global Catholic population has surpassed 1.4 billion.Eucharistic processions are drawing record crowds.

And last summer, more than 50,000 people packed into Indianapolis for the National Eucharistic Congress — the first of its kind in 83 years.But on the ground, the picture looks very different.Across the United States, dioceses are merging parishes, closing churches and asking fewer priests to cover more communities.Even as interest — especially among younger adults — begins to rebound, the Church keeps running into the same hard limit:It needs priests.And there aren’t enough of them.When asked about the priest shortage, Dan Monastra, a seminarian for the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, said, “One reason is the overall lack of desire in our culture to commit oneself to something permanent, especially among younger generations.

We see this not only with the priesthood but with marriage as well.Another reason is that the priesthood is antithetical to what modern culture offers; namely, comfort.”This is the paradox of the present moment: a renewed interest in Catholicism colliding with a severe priest shortage and the business of staffing, financing and sustaining parish life.

The Catholic population is growing with fewer priests to guide it.The priest shortage isn’t just a perception — it shows up clearly in the data.According to the Church’s statistical yearbook, the number of priests worldwide fell to 406,996 in 2023 — down from the year before and continuing a multiyear decline.The pipeline is shrinking, too.Globally, the number of seminarians dropped from 108,481 in 2022 to 106,495 in 2023 — part of a steady slide that’s now lasted more than a decade.That creates a long-term problem: fewer priests today means even fewer tomorrow.“With fewer priests to staff parishes, many dioceses across our country have engaged in restructuring or consolidating of parishes to deal with thi...