Why did Switzerlands Breel Embolo receive a red card against Argentina?

Switzerland’s World Cup ended in controversial fashion in a referee decision that will be debated long after the tournament ends.Swiss striker Breel Embolo was shown a second yellow card for simulation in the 72nd minute of Saturday night’s controversial 3-1 quarterfinal loss to Argentina at Arrowhead Stadium, a decision that completely changed the complexion of the match and left everyone involved with Switzerland furious.In real time, it looked as though Argentina midfielder Leandro Paredes had recklessly clipped Embolo inside the attacking third.Referee João Pinheiro immediately showed Paredes a yellow card, even as he claimed he didn’t make contact with Embolo.

Seconds later, the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) halted play and summoned the referee to the pitch-side monitor.What followed was easily one of the most controversial moments of the entire 2026 FIFA World Cup.After a lengthy review, Pinheiro overturned the yellow card against Paredes, and instead issued the card to Embolo.The referee ruled that Embolo had simulated the contact and under FIFA’s new mistaken identity rule, had to switch the yellow card from Paredes to the Swiss striker.

Embolo, who had already been shown a yellow card in the first half for a tough tackle, was shown a red card for accumulating two yellows and was sent off in tears as stunned teammates surrounded him.The new rule allows referees to reverse a booking if video determines the foul was actually committed by the opposing player.Or in this case, if no foul occurred at all and simulation was the real offense.

Without that new rule, Paredes would have remained booked and Embolo would have stayed on the field.If Paredes had already been shown a yellow card, he would have been the player sent off.The mistaken identity rule also occurred earlier in the tournament in the United States opening match against Paraguay.

Defender Tim Ream was shown a yellow card for a tackle on forward Miguel Almiron that would have given Paragua...