The rush to ban Central Park horse carriages is the true cruelty

Last month’s awful accident that killed 18-year-old tourist Romanch Mahajan has brought a stampede to ban the city’s horse-drawn carriages — context and even rational consideration be damned.Mahajan’s family testified at a City Council hearing Wednesday in favor of a ban; anyone listening would’ve had a hard time holding back tears.But New York City sees other deadly accidents all the time — without prompting a rush to outright ban cars, construction work or e-bikes.And the testimony from those in the industry — the ones who’d lose their livelihoods, not to mention, in all likelihood, their horses — was powerful, too.The city’s 200 or so drivers, mostly immigrants or immigrants’ children, average all of about $65,000 a year from the trade; the overwhelming majority who work as independent contractors or owner-operators get no employer medical insurance or other perks.For many, as one driver noted (an appeal to Mayor Zohran Mamdani and other socialists?), this is an industry where “the workers own the means of production.”What utter arrogance for council members to think they can write off the pain of destroying drivers’ careers simply by “retraining” them for other work.As a spokesman for the their union noted, the bill’s “worker development” provisions won’t lead to jobs that come anywhere near the ones the drivers now have.

Subscribe to our daily Post Opinion newsletter! Please provide a valid email.By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Never miss a story.As for the horses, the bill is a “death sentence,” one horse veterinarian testified: The idea that forcefully-retired equines will live out peaceful lives at pastoral sanctuaries is pure “fantasy.”In the background, the years-long drive for a ban relies on myths hyped up repeatedly by animal-rights fanatics about how the horses are supposedly “mistreated” and the rides “da...