Review: Lynn Novick's 'Crime and Punishment in America' takes a hard look at the criminal justice system

This is read by an automated voice.Please report any issues or inconsistencies here.
See more from the L.A.Times in Google Search.
Set us as preferred “Crime and Punishment in America,” running in four two-hour installments Monday through Thursday on PBS, travels across 250 years of American law and disorder.Written and directed by Ken Burns associate and collaborator Lynn Novick, it takes a big swing at a subject that could occupy an entire year of installments.
The point is made repeatedly that the U.S.incarcerates far more than its share of miscreants (20% of the world’s prison population, as of 2008, with the greatest number per capita).
We’re No.1!Novick tracks changing notions of what was considered a crime and what was considered a punishment, with the problem that the former did always not fit the latter — which is to say the punishment outstripped the crime.
It’s presented very much in the house style: stories of individuals chosen to illustrate a point knitted into a many-tendriled, overarching chronological narrative.It’s interesting, educational and admittedly inconclusive, but generally valuable as food for thought.Unlike some Burns and/or Novick projects (“Baseball,” “Jazz,” “The National Parks,” “Muhammad Ali”), the American saga the series is documenting is not calculated to fill you up with pride — although there have been moments when the prison builders or fixers felt they were onto something good, and obviously some (many?) who work in the field believe in their work.
(Though there is reportedly a high level of substance abuse, divorce and suicide for correctional officers.)Under the dulcet guidance of narrator Keith David, we begin in old colonial times when people would be punished in public.(Whippings, stocks, etc.) A really sensational hanging might draw thousands.
Moving this business behind closed doors was viewed as an enlightened advancement.“The reformation of a criminal can never be affe...