Fresh proof Hochul and Mamdani were clueless about their pied--terre tax

New figures from the Department of Finance make it painfully clear: Gov.Kathy Hochul and Mayor Zohran Mamdani had no idea what they were doing when they pushed through their pied-à-terre tax.The point was just to give the mayor a “tax the rich” victory; figuring out how anything actually works was irrelevant.

Consider: DOF now says only about 7,500 homeowners will get billed — less than half the 17,000 notices sent to potentially liable taxpayers and far less than the 13,000 the city and state originally expected to pay.AdvertisementNot to mention the “enemies list” of 900,000 properties — with names and addresses attached — that Mamdani’s team originally released as maybe subject to the tax.Yes, DOF now estimates that revenue from the tax — which hits second homes in the city worth more than $5 million, or more than $1 million for co-ops and condos — will still meet the $500 million projection (though the city refuses to show its math).But this means city and state number-crunchers were also way off in their estimates of the tax’s average hit on non-resident homeowners.AdvertisementBased on the new figures, that comes out to a small fortune: about $67,000 per unit — on top of existing property taxes: 19.843% on a Class 1 condo, so starting at $198,430 for a $1 million  pied-à-terre.It’s also in addition to other taxes — including state income taxes that many of these owners still pay.Which makes it a significant new incentive for these people to ditch the city altogether, no matter what Mamdani and his tax-the-rich base care to imagine.AdvertisementRemember: These semi-out-of-towners use far fewer city and state services (no public schools, just for starters) than full-time residents — since they’re not here most of the time.Yet they’re likely to be important contributors to the local economy — and to the city and state tax base.And to be donors to local charities.AdvertisementIf the additional tax prompts them to pick up st...

Read More 
PaprClips
Disclaimer: This story is auto-aggregated by a computer program and has not been created or edited by PaprClips.
Publisher: New York Post

Recent Articles