NJ dad admits fatally shooting stepdaughters French bulldog in the face first time he dog-sat

A vile New Jersey dad has admitted killing his stepdaughter’s French bulldog by shooting the puppy in the face while he was dog-sitting her for the first time.Jeffrey Lentz, 57, initially claimed that Ruby, a 1-year-old pup he and his wife were supposed to be looking after at their Toms River home, died in October 2025 after being attacked by an animal.But a necropsy “revealed that the wound to the dog’s face was from a gunshot, and an X-ray showed a bullet lodged in the dog’s jawbone,” the Ocean County Prosecutor’s Office said.Lentz pleaded guilty Monday to possession of a weapon for an unlawful purpose and animal cruelty, according to prosecutors — who are seeking a five-year prison sentence as well as “a lifetime ban from owning animals.”AdvertisementRuby’s owner, Nicole Guarino, previously said her mom, Lentz’s wife, called her with the heartbreaking news that her pup had died just hours after she and her husband, Nick, dropped the dog off at her parents’ home.“It was the first time we left her there for a sleepover,” Guarino previously told JerseyOnline.“I trusted them.What daughter wouldn’t trust her parents?”AdvertisementNicole said her mom told her Ruby had been attacked by an animal — but when she turned up with local cops, her parents “turned hostile.” “They handed Ruby to us in a box and closed the door,” Nicole said.“She was family,” she said of the slain pup.
“She was like our child.”AdvertisementLentz was arrested exactly a month later and booked into the Ocean County Jail.His guilty plea helped avoid a jury trial.Officials have yet to reveal why he would have shot and killed the dog.
He is scheduled to be sentenced on Jan.22, 2027.
The state is seeking concurrent terms of five years in state prison for the weapons offense and three years for the animal cruelty charge.Advertisement...