We need an independent probe of the deadly Brooklyn collapse and failed NYC oversight that led to it

The recent deadly collapse of excavation shoring at a construction site in Flatbush has focused attention on not only how the disaster occurred but the Department of Buildings as well.It’s time that the Mamdani administration appoint an independent blue-ribbon commission, composed of experts, to determine the specific facts on how the shoring panel failed and how the apartment building fell into the abyss, claiming eight lives and injuring over a dozen more.These people and their families deserve an unadulterated truthful report detailing how it happened. They are also entitled to know how the Department of Buildings failed them.AdvertisementIt’s been known that the New York City Department of Buildings is a city agency rife with problems.Inadequate staffing, low salaries, an enormous workload, and the reliance on third-party inspectors are just some of the more visible troubles within the bureaucratic morass.Old-school corruption in the form of bribes has surfaced with some regularity over the many decades of the department’s existence.
The fact that the commissioner of Buildings is no longer required to be a licensed architect or engineer — which started with the Bloomberg administration — is puzzling.AdvertisementOver 10 years ago I was named chairman of the commission to study the city of Philadelphia’s Department of Licenses and Inspections.
The commission was created in the wake of a deadly collapse that killed seven and injured 14 at a demolition site adjacent to an occupied Salvation Army thrift store.Nancy Winkler, who happened to be the city treasurer, lost her daughter in the collapse.
She advocated for the creation of an independent group to look at how the collapse occurred and how the city agency responsible for building inspections failed in its work.She encouraged Philadelphia Mayor Nutter to form the commission, and he did.The mayor’s charge to the commission included not only looking into the factors leading to the collapse but...