Mamdani faces major pied-a-terre tax embarrassment with NYC poised to send out just 8K bills

New York City is poised to mail pied-a-terre tax bills to roughly 8,000 homeowners — in an embarrassing blow for Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s levy and its ballyhooed revenue potential.That’s less than half of the roughly 17,000 notices the city sent out to properties in the summer alerting homeowners they may have to pay the surcharge, and 5,000 fewer than the revised 13,000 homes officials believed would be subject to the tax.Mamdani and New York Gov.Kathy Hochul announced the controversial tax on luxury second homes in the city worth over $5 million — or co-ops worth more than $1 million — and claimed it would generate $500 million-plus in revenue.AdvertisementOfficials initially sent out about 17,000 notices to properties in August, telling homeowners they could be taxed unless they could prove someone lives there for the majority of the year.However, City Hall was swiftly flooded by more than 10,000 exemption requests and at least 8,900 were granted, meaning only about 8,100 properties are expected to receive tax bills from the Department of Finance, officials told The Post.
That final number could be subject to change.AdvertisementThe setback comes after an appeals court in Brooklyn unanimously ruled earlier this month that Mamdani’s pied-à-terre tax rollout can proceed – in a big victory for the democratic socialist.The suit from a group of homeowners challenged the rollout of the tax — calling it “arbitrary and capricious” — and not the tax itself.AdvertisementWhile other challenges to the controversial tax remain, Hizzoner said he was “heartened” by the ruling and looked forward to defending the policy law in upcoming proceedings....