Undefeated NY high school football coach resigns after team is kicked out of playoffs over 53-second mistake

A New York head football coach resigned less than a week after his undefeated team was forced to forfeit a playoff win because they used an ineligible player for 53 seconds of the game.Tim Strenfel tendered his resignation from his post with the Middletown High School following the Section IX Class AA semifinal scandal that wiped away his team’s perfect season hopes, News12 and Mid-Hudson News reported.Strenfel had been at the helm of Middletown football for 10 years until he came under fire for putting a kicker, who was not cleared to play in any playoff games, into the crucial matchup.AdvertisementThe player had been on the Middletown Boys Soccer team before joining the football team in the middle of the regular season, which ended the year with a 9-1 record.He had been eligible to play in the regular-season contests but was ruled ineligible for the postseason because he did not appear on a roster for the minimum three regular-season games, according to the New York State Public High School Athletic Association guidelines.Middletown had defeated Valley Central 48-15 in its semifinal contest on Nov.
6.AdvertisementThe unidentified student-athlete – later ruled an ineligible kickoff specialist – had appeared for 8 plays lasting just under a minute of total gameplay during the win.After the game, coaches at Newburgh Free Academy – Middletown’s initial championship opponent – spotted the unrecognizable player and reported the incident to Valley Central officials.Valley Central Athletics Director reported the alleged offense to Section IX officials who reviewed the matter and ruled Middletown had to forfeit the win.AdvertisementThe Middies appealed the ruling, bringing the decision to the State Supreme Court but ultimately pulled their petition back after learning a judge wasn’t going to rule in their favor.Middletown officials called the forfeit “arbitrary and capricious,” blaming it on adult error that punished the kids.“While we are deeply, d...