Mamdanis cut-em-loose judicial picks are sure to slam public safety

Making New York City that much less safe, Mayor Zohran Mamdani has begun to ensure that more perps will walk by stacking the Criminal Court bench with judges biased against the prosecution.The mayor on Monday named his first five new picks for Criminal Court, three of them career public defenders, only two with real experience as prosecutors; at least three of his five Family Court choices also had strong Legal Aid-type backgrounds — and three of his six reappointments to the bench also cut their legal teeth as defense attorneys.Among those last is Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Valentina Morales, rightly dubbed “Judge Cut ’Em Loose” for her sky-high release rate for people arraigned on violent felony charges (82% for the first six months of 2024).The mayor also re-upped Queens Criminal Court Judge Jennifer Saint-Preux, a former Legal Aid lawyer who turned a blind eye to prosecutor pleas in August to lock up serial offender Shaquan Seth — despite a rap sheet boasting nearly 150 busts — and instead ordered him held on $100,000 bond.AdvertisementThis was the first taste of Mamdani’s judge-picking, after a dozen earlier choices that had been vetted under the last mayor.It’s a clear sign of where he’ll steer the 107-judge-strong Criminal Court bench, and every pick serves a 10-year term so the impact will be long-lasting.(Civil Court judges, who are elected routinely, get seconded to Criminal Court duty and often show their own pro-defense bias.)Inclined to think defendants, no matter how heinous their crimes, should get counseling, not incarceration, these former public defenders will surely prove less willing to order bail for the accused, and more likely to find alternatives to prison for perps found guilty.AdvertisementThat means more dangerous career criminals left walking free, in a city whose police force the mayor refuses to expand and as he anticipates a drastic reduction in available jail space under the “replace Rikers” plan.

Plainly, M...

Read More 
PaprClips
Disclaimer: This story is auto-aggregated by a computer program and has not been created or edited by PaprClips.
Publisher: New York Post

Recent Articles