Mamdanis 5-year Rikers pause solves a legal headache and sets up a worse one

Last week Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced that he’ll ask the City Council to delay its deadline for shuttering the jails on Rikers Island from 2027 to 2032.If they do so, the mayor and council will cure one legal problem that plagues their plan for Rikers’ closure — but leave another far more serious and dangerous legal flaw unresolved.Under New York state’s Correction Law, the city cannot close its current jails until it has “designated or erected” replacement facilities.That means the 2027 closure deadline set by the City Council’s local law is nothing but an unenforceable aspiration: Rikers may only close entirely when the city has erected new jails to take its place.AdvertisementBy moving the deadline at the mayor’s request, the council simply avoids an imminent and impractical conflict with state law. A more pressing and dangerous legal problem looms, though.The four borough-based jails slated to replace the Rikers facilities will have only a fraction of Rikers’ capacity.AdvertisementThe Rikers jails can hold about 15,000 inmates, and they house more than 6,600 people now.The four new jails will have a combined capacity of about 4,100 inmates.That substantial difference is no oversight — it has been, from the beginning, the plan’s foundation.Ever since Mayor Bill de Blasio announced the closure plan in 2019, throughout Mayor Eric Adams’ tenure and continuing into the Mamdani administration, the city has openly touted “decarceration” as the primary purpose behind the “close Rikers” push.AdvertisementAs the mayor’s office website currently proclaims, “New York is leading a historic decarceration plan to close Rikers Island and replace it with a smaller network of safer modern jails.”The city is deliberately building a jail system that slashes capacity — not because of a reduced need for jail cells, but because of an ideological antipathy to incarceration.State law and the constitutional prerogatives of the judicial b...